Real english and english lite : what texts should we teach in the english classroom? (1) or English lite and thick lit : what is the debate about?
Data(s) |
01/01/2006
|
---|---|
Resumo |
Why is it that Prime Minister John Howard wants to micro-manage English curricula? Why does how teachers teach English and Literature regularly make it to the front and editorial pages of the national dailies? The author attempts to critique that phenomenon, to explain her state of mind - that of being both alert and alarmed. The latest round of the debate began with Tony Thompson's article, 'English Lite is a tragedy for students', in 'The Age' on 12 September 2005. He was concerned that VCE English might be reduced to a single print text and he was alarmed about the watering-down of curriculum driven by 'postmodern notions'. The author is at odds with many of Thompson's views and discusses her stance on various aspects of his propositions. Issues examined include Thompson's argument that no multimodal text yields as much significance as a piece of genuine literature; that students are not being 'stretched' far enough; the false dichotomy between aesthetic/formalist manoeuvres on the one hand and postmodern ones on the other; how texts make meaning to students as consumers and the rationale for the use of pop culture texts to connect with students.<br /> |
Identificador | |
Idioma(s) |
eng |
Publicador |
Victorian Association for the Teaching of English |
Relação |
http://dro.deakin.edu.au/eserv/DU:30003725/devlin-glass-realenglishandenglishlite-2006.pdf http://dro.deakin.edu.au/eserv/DU:30003725/n20060658.pdf |
Direitos |
2006, Victorian Association for the Teaching of English |
Palavras-Chave | #curriculum guides #English curriculum #English literature #English teachers #English teaching #literacy #literary genres #nonprint media #popular culture #secondary school curriculum |
Tipo |
Journal Article |