Hospital transfers between Swiss cantons: a first look

Objective: To assess the importance of hospital transfers between Swiss cantons and the factors associated with them. Methods: Hospital discharge data, mean number of hospitals, hospital beds and corresponding density per 100.000 inhabitants for period 1998-2008 were provided by the Federal Office of Statistics. Inclusion criteria were: >=18 years; transferred from one hospital to another and living in a canton different from the one they were transferred to. Cumulative data for the study period was used. Results: Between 1998 and 2008, 247.355 hospital transfers occurred between cantons, representing 17.7% of all hospital transfers. This value ranged between 2.7% (Geneva) and 81.6% (Appenzell Innerrhoden). The main diagnoses were: circulatory system (20.1%); musculoskeletal system (9.3%); mental and behavioural disorders (6.5%); oncology (4.6%) and repertories diseases (2.6%). Factors influencing health status (28.7%) and injuries and external causes (12%) were not included in the analysis. Cantons with a university hospital received more patients than they transferred to other cantons. The other cantons were either "senders" or "receivers" according to the disease considered. German-speaking cantons transferred patients more easily than the others. Most transfers were made between geographically or linguistically close cantons. The number of patients received was associated with the number of hospitals (r = 0.82, p <0.001) or beds (r = 0.85, p <0.001)in the canton; bed density (r = 0.51, p <0.01), but not with hospital density(r = 0.08, p <0.7). Conclusions: in Switzerland, over one-sixth of hospital transfers occur between cantons. Several cantons are dependent of others for the treatment of specific diseases. Cantons with a university hospital attract more patients, suggesting an optimisation of health resources.