Polyethylene wear in anatomic and reversed shoulder prostheses

Purpose: Polyethylene wear is a recurrent problem in joint arthroplasty. Small debris particles are also associated to inflammation reaction of the surrounding bone, eventually leading to the failure of the bound between the implant and the host bone, and implant loosening. The goal of this study was thus to estimate the volume of polyethylene wear of a reversed prosthesis, and compare it to an anatomic prosthesis, during one year of activities of daily living. Material and Methods: A numerical musculoskeletal model of the glenohumeral joint was used for this comparative study. The reversed (RP) and anatomic (AP) Aequalis prostheses were positioned in the numerical model. Eight levels of abduction were considered. Their daily frequency was estimated from in-vivo recorded data on healthy volunteers during activities of daily living. One year of use was simulated to predict the linear and volumetric wear. The volumetric wear was the difference of volume between the original and worn component. Results: With the AP, the contact pattern on the glenoid surface moved rapidly from the inferior to the superior side during the first 30 degrees of abduction, and then went back to the inferior side. With the RP, the contact pattern on the humeral cup surface remained at the inferior side. Contact pressure was 20 times lower with the RP than with the AP. One year of use produced a maximum linear wear of 0.2 mm with the AP, and 0.13 mm with the RP. However, the volumetric wear was 8.4 mm3 with the AP, but reached 44.6 mm3 with the RP. Conclusion: Polyethylene particles are a matter of concern with AP. Infiltration of these particles within the bone-implant interface can induce a implant loosening. This problem should not be underestimated with RP. It might be associated to a higher level of humeral stem loosening reported with RP. The long term survival of RP might be improved by using a highly cross-linked polyethylene, which has a better abrasion resistance but lower plastic resistance.