Planning and governance approaches for protecting World Heritage Areas: A comparison of the Great Barrier Reef and the Florida Everglades


Autoria(s): Sipe, Neil; Vella, Karen
Data(s)

30/10/2014

Resumo

The focus of this paper is on two World Heritage Areas: the Great Barrier Reef in Queensland, Australia and the Everglades in Florida. While both are World Heritage listed by the UNESCO, the Everglades is on the "World Heritage in Danger" list and the Great Barrier Reef could be on this list within the next year if present pressures continue. This paper examines the planning approaches and governance structures used in these two areas (Queensland and Florida) to manage the growth and development pressures. To make the analysis manageable, given the scale of these World Heritage areas, case studies at the local government level will be used: the Cairns Regional Council in Queensland and Monroe County in Florida. The case study analysis will involve three steps: (1) examination of the various plans at the federal, state, local levels that impact upon environmental quality in the Great Barrier Reef and Everglades; (2) assessing the degree to which these plans have been implemented; and (3) determine if (and how) the plans have improved environmental quality. In addition to the planning analysis we will also examine the governance structures (Lebel et al. 2006) within which planning operates. In any comparative analysis context is important (Hantrais 2009). Contextual differences between Queensland and Florida have previously been examined by Sipe, et al. (2007) and will be used as the starting point for this analysis. Our operating hypothesis and preliminary analysis suggests that the planning approaches and governance structures used in Florida and Queensland are considerably different, but the environmental outcomes may be similar. This is based, in part, on Vella (2004) who did a comparative analysis of environmental practices in the sugar industry in Florida and Queensland. This research re-examines this hypothesis and broadens the focus beyond the sugar industry to growth and development more broadly.

Identificador

http://eprints.qut.edu.au/82616/

Relação

http://www.acsp.org/sites/default/files/COMPLETED%20book%20of%20conference%20abstracts_0.pdf

Sipe, Neil & Vella, Karen (2014) Planning and governance approaches for protecting World Heritage Areas: A comparison of the Great Barrier Reef and the Florida Everglades. In Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning Conference, 30 October - 2 November 2014, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Unpublished)

Direitos

Copyright 2014 [please consult the authors]

Fonte

School of Civil Engineering & Built Environment; Institute for Future Environments; Science & Engineering Faculty

Palavras-Chave #120504 Land Use and Environmental Planning #Everglades #Great Barrier Reef #governance #environmental planning #comprehensive planning #environment
Tipo

Conference Item