“A politics of what” : A praxiography of renal disease in Indigenous renal patients


Autoria(s): McCarthy, Alexandra; Martin-McDonald, Kristine
Data(s)

01/09/2006

Resumo

The morbidity and mortality rates of renal disease in Indigenous Australians are significantly higher than those of non-Indigenous Australians, and are increasing. The dominant discourses of renal disease currently predicate this as essentially a client problem, rather than (for example) a health care system problem. These discourses are indicative of the dominant “white” paradigm of health care, which fosters an expectation of assimilation by the marginalised “other.” In this paper, we draw upon a sociological methodology (the actor network approach) and a qualitative method (discourse analysis) to tease out these issues in Indigenous renal disease. Based on empirical data, we explore on the one hand the requirements of the discourses, technologies and practices that have been developed for a particular type of renal patient and health system in Australia. On the other, we examine the cultural and practical specificities entailed in the performance of these technologies and practices in the Indigenous Australian context. The meeting of the praxiographic orientation of the actor network approach—which has been called “the politics of what” (Mol 2002)—and the sociocultural concerns of discourse analysis does provide a useful guide as to “what to do” when confronted with issues in health care that currently seems unfathomable. Our praxiographic analysis of the discourse enabled us to understand the difficulties involved in translating renal health care networks across cultural contexts in Australia and to understand the dynamic and contested nature of these networks. The actor network approach has its limitations, however, particularly in the articulation of possible strategies to align two disparate systems in a way that would ensure better health care for Indigenous renal patients. In this paper we will discuss some of the problems we encountered in drawing on this methodology in our attempt to unearth practical solutions to the conundrums our data presented.

Identificador

http://eprints.qut.edu.au/64549/

Publicador

University of Alberta

Relação

http://ejournals.library.ualberta.ca/index.php/IJQM/article/view/4373

McCarthy, Alexandra & Martin-McDonald, Kristine (2006) “A politics of what” : A praxiography of renal disease in Indigenous renal patients. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 5(3), p. 51.

Fonte

Faculty of Health; Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation; School of Nursing

Palavras-Chave #110000 MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES #111000 NURSING #praxiography #renal disease #Indigenous Australians #Indigenous patients #Australia #qualitative
Tipo

Journal Article