Biosensors based on vertically interrogated optofluidic sensing cells

El objetivo de la presente tesis doctoral es el desarrollo de un nuevo concepto de biosensor óptico sin marcado, basado en una combinación de técnicas de caracterización óptica de interrogación vertical y estructuras sub-micrométricas fabricadas sobre chips de silicio. Las características más importantes de dicho dispositivo son su simplicidad, tanto desde el punto de vista de medida óptica como de introducción de las muestras a medir en el área sensible, aspectos que suelen ser críticos en la mayoría de sensores encontrados en la literatura. Cada uno de los aspectos relacionados con el diseño de un biosensor, que son fundamentalmente cuatro (diseño fotónico, caracterización óptica, fabricación y fluídica/inmovilización química) son desarrollados en detalle en los capítulos correspondientes. En la primera parte de la tesis se hace una introducción al concepto de biosensor, en qué consiste, qué tipos hay y cuáles son los parámetros más comunes usados para cuantificar su comportamiento. Posteriormente se realiza un análisis del estado del arte en la materia, enfocado en particular en el área de biosensores ópticos sin marcado. Se introducen también cuáles son las reacciones bioquímicas a estudiar (inmunoensayos). En la segunda parte se describe en primer lugar cuáles son las técnicas ópticas empleadas en la caracterización: Reflectometría, Elipsometría y Espectrometría; además de los motivos que han llevado a su empleo. Posteriormente se introducen diversos diseños de las denominadas "celdas optofluídicas", que son los dispositivos en los que se va a producir la interacción bioquímica. Se presentan cuatro dispositivos diferentes, y junto con ellos, se proponen diversos métodos de cálculo teórico de la respuesta óptica esperada. Posteriormente se procede al cálculo de la sensibilidad esperada para cada una de las celdas, así como al análisis de los procesos de fabricación de cada una de ellas y su comportamiento fluídico. Una vez analizados todos los aspectos críticos del comportamiento del biosensor, se puede realizar un proceso de optimización de su diseño. Esto se realiza usando un modelo de cálculo simplificado (modelo 1.5-D) que permite la obtención de parámetros como la sensibilidad y el límite de detección de un gran número de dispositivos en un tiempo relativamente reducido. Para este proceso se escogen dos de las celdas optofluídicas propuestas. En la parte final de la tesis se muestran los resultados experimentales obtenidos. En primer lugar, se caracteriza una celda basada en agujeros sub-micrométricos como sensor de índice de refracción, usando para ello diferentes líquidos orgánicos; dichos resultados experimentales presentan una buena correlación con los cálculos teóricos previos, lo que permite validar el modelo conceptual presentado. Finalmente, se realiza un inmunoensayo químico sobre otra de las celdas propuestas (pilares nanométricos de polímero SU-8). Para ello se utiliza el inmunoensayo de albumina de suero bovino (BSA) y su anticuerpo (antiBSA). Se detalla el proceso de obtención de la celda, la funcionalización de la superficie con los bioreceptores (en este caso, BSA) y el proceso de biorreconocimiento. Este proceso permite dar una primera estimación de cuál es el límite de detección esperable para este tipo de sensores en un inmunoensayo estándar. En este caso, se alcanza un valor de 2.3 ng/mL, que es competitivo comparado con otros ensayos similares encontrados en la literatura. La principal conclusión de la tesis es que esta tipología de dispositivos puede ser usada como inmunosensor, y presenta ciertas ventajas respecto a los actualmente existentes. Estas ventajas vienen asociadas, de nuevo, a su simplicidad, tanto a la hora de medir ópticamente, como dentro del proceso de introducción de los bioanalitos en el área sensora (depositando simplemente una gota sobre la micro-nano-estructura). Los cálculos teorícos realizados en los procesos de optimización sugieren a su vez que el comportamiento del sensor, medido en magnitudes como límite de detección biológico puede ser ampliamente mejorado con una mayor compactación de pilares, alcanzandose un valor mínimo de 0.59 ng/mL). The objective of this thesis is to develop a new concept of optical label-free biosensor, based on a combination of vertical interrogation optical techniques and submicron structures fabricated over silicon chips. The most important features of this device are its simplicity, both from the point of view of optical measurement and regarding to the introduction of samples to be measured in the sensing area, which are often critical aspects in the majority of sensors found in the literature. Each of the aspects related to the design of biosensors, which are basically four (photonic design, optical characterization, fabrication and fluid / chemical immobilization) are developed in detail in the relevant chapters. The first part of the thesis consists of an introduction to the concept of biosensor: which elements consists of, existing types and the most common parameters used to quantify its behavior. Subsequently, an analysis of the state of the art in this area is presented, focusing in particular in the area of label free optical biosensors. What are also introduced to study biochemical reactions (immunoassays). The second part describes firstly the optical techniques used in the characterization: reflectometry, ellipsometry and spectrometry; in addition to the reasons that have led to their use. Subsequently several examples of the so-called "optofluidic cells" are introduced, which are the devices where the biochemical interactions take place. Four different devices are presented, and their optical response is calculated by using various methods. Then is exposed the calculation of the expected sensitivity for each of the cells, and the analysis of their fabrication processes and fluidic behavior at the sub-micrometric range. After analyzing all the critical aspects of the biosensor, it can be performed a process of optimization of a particular design. This is done using a simplified calculation model (1.5-D model calculation) that allows obtaining parameters such as sensitivity and the detection limit of a large number of devices in a relatively reduced time. For this process are chosen two different optofluidic cells, from the four previously proposed. The final part of the thesis is the exposition of the obtained experimental results. Firstly, a cell based sub-micrometric holes is characterized as refractive index sensor using different organic fluids, and such experimental results show a good correlation with previous theoretical calculations, allowing to validate the conceptual model presented. Finally, an immunoassay is performed on another typology of cell (SU-8 polymer pillars). This immunoassay uses bovine serum albumin (BSA) and its antibody (antiBSA). The processes for obtaining the cell surface functionalization with the bioreceptors (in this case, BSA) and the biorecognition (antiBSA) are detailed. This immunoassay can give a first estimation of which are the expected limit of detection values for this typology of sensors in a standard immunoassay. In this case, it reaches a value of 2.3 ng/mL, which is competitive with other similar assays found in the literature. The main conclusion of the thesis is that this type of device can be used as immunosensor, and has certain advantages over the existing ones. These advantages are associated again with its simplicity, by the simpler coupling of light and in the process of introduction of bioanalytes into the sensing areas (by depositing a droplet over the micro-nano-structure). Theoretical calculations made in optimizing processes suggest that the sensor Limit of detection can be greatly improved with higher compacting of the lattice of pillars, reaching a minimum value of 0.59 ng/mL).

Crecimiento, fabricación y caracterización de heteroestructuras y nanocolumnas ordenadas basadas en nitruros del grupo III para aplicaciones sensoras

Esta memoria está basada en el crecimiento y caracterización de heteroestructuras Al(Ga)N/GaN y nanocolumnas ordenadas de GaN, y su aplicación en sensores químicos. El método de crecimiento ha sido la epitaxia de haces moleculares asistida por plasma (PAMBE). En el caso de las heteroestructuras Al(Ga)N/GaN, se han crecido barreras de distinto espesor y composición, desde AlN de 5 nm, hasta AlGaN de 35 nm. Además de una caracterización morfológica, estructural y eléctrica básica de las capas, también se han fabricado a partir de ellas dispositivos tipo HEMTs. La caracterización eléctrica de dichos dispositivos (carga y movilidad de en el canal bidimensional) indica que las mejores heteroestructuras son aquellas con un espesor de barrera intermedio (alrededor de 20 nm). Sin embargo, un objetivo importante de esta Tesis ha sido verificar las ventajas que podían tener los sensores basados en heteroestructuras AlN/GaN (frente a los típicos basados en AlGaN/GaN), con espesores de barrera muy finos (alrededor de 5 nm), ya que el canal de conducción que se modula por efecto de cambios químicos está más cerca de la superficie en donde ocurren dichos cambios químicos. De esta manera, se han utilizado los dispositivos tipo HEMTs como sensores químicos de pH (ISFETs), y se ha comprobado la mayor sensibilidad (variación de corriente frente a cambios de pH, Ids/pH) en los sensores basados en AlN/GaN frente a los basados en AlGaN/GaN. La mayor sensibilidad es incluso más patente en aplicaciones en las que no se utiliza un electrodo de referencia. Se han fabricado y caracterizado dispositivos ISFET similares utilizando capas compactas de InN. Estos sensores presentan peor estabilidad que los basados en Al(Ga)N/GaN, aunque la sensibilidad superficial al pH era la misma (Vgs/pH), y su sensibilidad en terminos de corriente de canal (Ids/pH) arroja valores intermedios entre los ISFET basados en AlN/GaN y los valores de los basados en AlGaN/GaN. Para continuar con la comparación entre dispositivos basados en Al(Ga)N/GaN, se fabricaron ISFETs con el área sensible más pequeña (35 x 35 m2), de tamaño similar a los dispositivos destinados a las medidas de actividad celular. Sometiendo los dispositivos a pulsos de voltaje en su área sensible, la respuesta de los dispositivos de AlN presentaron menor ruido que los basados en AlGaN. El ruido en la corriente para dispositivos de AlN, donde el encapsulado no ha sido optimizado, fue tan bajo como 8.9 nA (valor rms), y el ruido equivalente en el potencial superficial 38.7 V. Estos valores son más bajos que los encontrados en los dispositivos típicos para la detección de actividad celular (basados en Si), y del orden de los mejores resultados encontrados en la literatura sobre AlGaN/GaN. Desde el punto de vista de la caracterización electro-química de las superficies de GaN e InN, se ha determinado su punto isoeléctrico. Dicho valor no había sido reportado en la literatura hasta el momento. El valor, determinado por medidas de “streaming potential”, es de 4.4 y 4 respectivamente. Este valor es una importante característica a tener en cuenta en sensores, en inmovilización electrostática o en la litografía coloidal. Esta última técnica se discute en esta memoria, y se aplica en el último bloque de investigación de esta Tesis (i.e. crecimiento ordenado). El último apartado de resultados experimentales de esta Tesis analiza el crecimiento selectivo de nanocolumnas ordenadas de GaN por MBE, utilizando mascaras de Ti con nanoagujeros. Se ha estudiado como los distintos parámetros de crecimiento (i.e. flujos de los elementos Ga y N, temperatura de crecimiento y diseño de la máscara) afectan a la selectividad y a la morfología de las nanocolumnas. Se ha conseguido con éxito el crecimiento selectivo sobre pseudosustratos de GaN con distinta orientación cristalina o polaridad; templates de GaN(0001)/zafiro, GaN(0001)/AlN/Si, GaN(000-1)/Si y GaN(11-20)/zafiro. Se ha verificado experimentalmente la alta calidad cristalina de las nanocolumnas ordenadas, y su mayor estabilidad térmica comparada con las capas compactas del mismo material. Las nanocolumnas ordenadas de nitruros del grupo III tienen una clara aplicación en el campo de la optoelectrónica, principalmente para nanoemisores de luz blanca. Sin embargo, en esta Tesis se proponen como alternativa a la utilización de capas compactas o nanocolumnas auto-ensambladas en sensores. Las nanocolumnas auto-ensambladas de GaN, debido a su alta razón superficie/volumen, son muy prometedoras en el campo de los sensores, pero su amplia dispersión en dimensiones (altura y diámetro) supone un problema para el procesado y funcionamiento de dispositivos reales. En ese aspecto, las nanocolumnas ordenadas son más robustas y homogéneas, manteniendo una alta relación superficie/volumen. Como primer experimento en el ámbito de los sensores, se ha estudiado como se ve afectada la emisión de fotoluminiscencia de las NCs ordenadas al estar expuestas al aire o al vacio. Se observa una fuerte caída en la intensidad de la fotoluminiscencia cuando las nanocolumnas están expuestas al aire (probablemente por la foto-adsorción de oxigeno en la superficie), como ya había sido documentado anteriormente en nanocolumnas auto-ensambladas. Este experimento abre el camino para futuros sensores basados en nanocolumnas ordenadas. Abstract This manuscript deals with the growth and characterization of Al(Ga)N/GaN heterostructures and GaN ordered nanocolumns, and their application in chemical sensors. The growth technique has been the plasma-assisted molecular beam epitaxy (PAMBE). In the case of Al(Ga)N/GaN heterostructures, barriers of different thickness and composition, from AlN (5 nm) to AlGaN (35 nm) have been grown. Besides the basic morphological, structural and electrical characterization of the layers, HEMT devices have been fabricated based on these layers. The best electrical characteristics (larger carriers concentration and mobility in the two dimensional electron gas) are those in AlGaN/GaN heterostructures with a medium thickness (around 20 nm). However, one of the goals of this Thesis has been to verify the advantages that sensors based on AlN/GaN (thickness around 7 nm) have compared to standard AlGaN/GaN, because the conduction channel to be modulated by chemical changes is closer to the sensitive area. In this way, HEMT devices have been used as chemical pH sensors (ISFETs), and the higher sensitivity (conductance change related to pH changes, Ids/pH) of AlN/GaN based sensors has been proved. The higher sensibility is even more obvious in application without reference electrode. Similar ISFETs devices have been fabricated based on InN compact layers. These devices show a poor stability, but its surface sensitivity to pH (Vgs/pH) and its sensibility (Ids/pH) yield values between the corresponding ones of AlN/GaN and AlGaN/GaN heterostructures. In order to a further comparison between Al(Ga)N/GaN based devices, ISFETs with smaller sensitive area (35 x 35 m2), similar to the ones used in cellular activity record, were fabricated and characterized. When the devices are subjected to a voltage pulse through the sensitive area, the response of AlN based devices shows lower noise than the ones based on AlGaN. The noise in the current of such a AlN based device, where the encapsulation has not been optimized, is as low as 8.9 nA (rms value), and the equivalent noise to the surface potential is 38.7 V. These values are lower than the found in typical devices used for cellular activity recording (based on Si), and in the range of the best published results on AlGaN/GaN. From the point of view of the electrochemical characterization of GaN and InN surfaces, their isoelectric point has been experimentally determined. Such a value is the first time reported for GaN and InN surfaces. These values are determined by “streaming potential”, being pH 4.4 and 4, respectively. Isoelectric point value is an important characteristic in sensors, electrostatic immobilization or in colloidal lithography. In particular, colloidal lithography has been optimized in this Thesis for GaN surfaces, and applied in the last part of experimental results (i.e. ordered growth). The last block of this Thesis is focused on the selective area growth of GaN nanocolumns by MBE, using Ti masks decorated with nanoholes. The effect of the different growth parameters (Ga and N fluxes, growth temperature and mask design) is studied, in particular their impact in the selectivity and in the morphology of the nanocolumns. Selective area growth has been successful performed on GaN templates with different orientation or polarity; GaN(0001)/sapphire, GaN(0001)/AlN/Si, GaN(000- 1)/Si and GaN(11-20)/sapphire. Ordered nanocolumns exhibit a high crystal quality, and a higher thermal stability (lower thermal decomposition) than the compact layers of the same material. Ordered nanocolumns based on III nitrides have a clear application in optoelectronics, mainly for white light nanoemitters. However, this Thesis proposes them as an alternative to compact layers and self-assembled nanocolumns in sensor applications. Self-assembled GaN nanocolumns are very appealing for sensor applications, due to their large surface/volume ratio. However, their large dispersion in heights and diameters are a problem in terms of processing and operation of real devices. In this aspect, ordered nanocolumns are more robust and homogeneous, keeping the large surface/volume ratio. As first experimental evidence of their sensor capabilities, ordered nanocolumns have been studied regarding their photoluminiscence on air and vacuum ambient. A big drop in the intensity is observed when the nanocolumns are exposed to air (probably because of the oxygen photo-adsortion), as was already reported in the case of self-assembled nanocolumns. This opens the way to future sensors based on ordered III nitrides nanocolumns.

Biomolecular interaction analysis of gestrinone-anti-gestrinone using arrays of high aspect ratio SU-8 nanopillars

In this paper, label-free biosensing for antibody screening by periodic lattices of high-aspect ratio SU-8 nano-pillars (BICELLs) is presented. As a demonstration, the determination of anti-gestrinone antibodies from whole rabbit serum is carried out, and for the first time, the dissociation constant (KD = 6 nM) of antigen-antibody recognition process is calculated using this sensing system. After gestrinone antigen immobilization on the BICELLs, the immunorecognition was performed. The cells were interrogated vertically by using micron spot size Fourier transform visible and IR spectrometry (FT-VIS-IR), and the dip wavenumber shift was monitored. The biosensing assay exhibited good reproducibility and sensitivity (LOD = 0.75 ng/mL).

The potential of organic fertilizers and water management to reduce N2O emissions in Mediterranean climate cropping systems. A review.

Environmental problems related to the use of synthetic fertilizers and to organic waste management have led to increased interest in the use of organic materials as an alternative source of nutrients for crops, but this is also associated with N2O emissions. There has been an increasing amount of research into the effects of using different types of fertilization on N2O emissions under Mediterranean climatic conditions, but the findings have sometimes been rather contradictory. Available information also suggests that water management could exert a high influence on N2O emissions. In this context, we have reviewed the current scientific knowledge, including an analysis of the effect of fertilizer type and water management on direct N2O emissions. A meta-analysis of compliant reviewed experiments revealed significantly lower N2O emissions for organic as opposed to synthetic fertilizers (23% reduction). When organic materials were segregated in solid and liquid, only solid organic fertilizer emissions were significantly lower than those of synthetic fertilizers (28% reduction in cumulative emissions). The EF is similar to the IPCC factor in conventionally irrigated systems (0.98% N2O-N N applied−1), but one order of magnitude lower in rainfed systems (0.08%). Drip irrigation produces intermediate emission levels (0.66%). Differences are driven by Mediterranean agro-climatic characteristics, which include low soil organic matter (SOM) content and a distinctive rainfall and temperature pattern. Interactions between environmental and management factors and the microbial processes involved in N2O emissions are discussed in detail. Indirect emissions have not been fully accounted for, but when organic fertilizers are applied at similar N rates to synthetic fertilizers, they generally make smaller contributions to the leached NO3− pool. The most promising practices for reducing N2O through organic fertilization include: (i) minimizing water applications; (ii) minimizing bare soil; (iii) improving waste management; and (iv) tightening N cycling through N immobilization. The mitigation potential may be limited by: (i) residual effect; (ii) the long-term effects of fertilizers on SOM; (iii) lower yield-scaled performance; and (iv) total N availability from organic sources. Knowledge gaps identified in the review included: (i) insufficient sampling periods; (ii) high background emissions; (iii) the need to provide N2O EF and yield-scaled EF; (iv) the need for more research on specific cropping systems; and (v) the need for full GHG balances. In conclusion, the available information suggests a potential of organic fertilizers and water-saving practices to mitigate N2O emissions under Mediterranean climatic conditions, although further research is needed before it can be regarded as fully proven, understood and developed.

Building functional surfaces for biosensors development

Polyelectrolyte multilayers (PEM) built by layer-by-layer technique have been extensively studied over the last years, resulting in a wide variety of current and potential applications. This technique can be used to construct thin films with different functionalities, or to functionalize surfaces with substantial different properties of those of the underlying substrates. The multilayering process is achieved by the alternate adsorption of oppositely charged polyelectrolytes. In this work we get advantage of the protein resistant property of the Poly (l-lysine)-graft-(polyethyleneglycol) to create protein patterns. Proteins can be immobilized on a surface by unspecific physical adsorption, covalent binding or through specific interactions. The first protein used in this work was laccase, a copper-containing redox enzyme that catalyse the oxidation of a broad range of polyphenols and aromatic substrates, coupled to the reduction of O2 to H2O without need of cofactors. Applications of laccases have been reported in food, pulp, paper, and textile industry, and also in biosensor development. Some uses require the immobilization of the enzyme on solid supports by adsorption, covalent attachment, entrapment, etc, on several substrates. Especially for biosensor development, highly active, stable and reproducible immobilization of laccase is required.

Development of a versatile biotinylated material based on SU-8

The negative epoxy-based SU-8 photoresist has a wide variety of applications within the semiconductor industry, photonics and lab-on-a-chip devices, and it is emerging as an alternative to silicon-based devices for sensing purposes. In the present work, biotinylation of the SU-8 polymer surface promoted by light is reported. As a result, a novel, efective, and low-cost material, focusing on the immobilization of bioreceptors and consequent biosensing, is developed. This material allows the spatial discrimination depending on the irradiation of desired areas. The most salient feature is that the photobiotin may be directly incorporated into the SU-8 curing process, consequently reducing time and cost. The potential use of this substrate is demonstrated by the immunoanalytical detection of the synthetic steroid gestrinone, showing excellent performances. Moreover, the naked eye biodetection due to the transparent SU-8 substrate, and simple instrumental quantication are additional advantages.

Initializing the DSSAT-Century model: inverse calibration of carbon pools from apparent soil N mineralization

The CENTURY soil organic matter model was adapted for the DSSAT (Decision Support System for Agrotechnology Transfer), modular format in order to better simulate the dynamics of soil organic nutrient processes (Gijsman et al., 2002). The CENTURY model divides the soil organic carbon (SOC) into three hypothetical pools: microbial or active material (SOC1), intermediate (SOC2) and the largely inert and stable material (SOC3) (Jones et al., 2003). At the beginning of the simulation, CENTURY model needs a value of SOC3 per soil layer which can be estimated by the model (based on soil texture and management history) or given as an input. Then, the model assigns about 5% and 95% of the remaining SOC to SOC1 and SOC2, respectively. The model performance when simulating SOC and nitrogen (N) dynamics strongly depends on the initialization process. The common methods (e.g. Basso et al., 2011) to initialize SOC pools deal mostly with carbon (C) mineralization processes and less with N. Dynamics of SOM, SOC, and soil organic N are linked in the CENTURY-DSSAT model through the C/N ratio of decomposing material that determines either mineralization or immobilization of N (Gijsman et al., 2002). The aim of this study was to evaluate an alternative method to initialize the SOC pools in the DSSAT-CENTURY model from apparent soil N mineralization (Napmin) field measurements by using automatic inverse calibration (simulated annealing). The results were compared with the ones obtained by the iterative initialization procedure developed by Basso et al., 2011.

Topographical and mechanical characterization of living eukaryotic cells on opaque substrates: development of a general procedure and its application to the study of non-adherent lymphocytes

The mechanical behavior of living murine T-lymphocytes was assessed by atomic force microscopy (AFM). A robust experimental procedure was developed to overcome some features of lymphocytes, in particular their spherical shape and non-adherent character. The procedure included the immobilization of the lymphocytes on amine-functionalized substrates, the use of hydrodynamic effects on the deflection of the AFM cantilever to monitor the approaching, and the use of the jumping mode for obtaining the images. Indentation curves were analyzed according to Hertz's model for contact mechanics. The calculated values of the elastic modulus are consistent both when considering the results obtained from a single lymphocyte and when comparing the curves recorded from cells of different specimens